Br. Donald “Alois” O’Toole – Archdiocese of Baltimore

by | Aug 7, 2023 | Abuser Profiles, Catholic Church

Br. Donald “Alois” O’Toole

Archdiocese of Baltimore/Xaverian Brothers

Br. Donald "Alois" O'Toole Horowitz Law


Joined: 1935

Removed: 1989

Died: 2006


Assignment History:

  • 1940-1941      Xavier, Louisville, KY
  • 1942-1951      Cardinal Hayes, Bronx, NY
  • 1952-1957      Archbishop Stepinac, White Plains, NY
  • 1958               Mount St. Joseph, Baltimore, MD
  • 1959-1963      East Africa     
  • 1964-1966      John’s High School, Shrewsbury, MA
  • 1967-1975      East Africa
  • 1976-1989      John’s High School, Shrewsbury, MA


Summary of Abuse Allegations Against Br. “Alois” O’Toole:

Br. Donald O’Toole is one of the priests identified by the Maryland Attorney General as having been accused of sexually abusing minors and having been assigned or resided in the Archdiocese of Baltimore.


According to the Attorney General’s report, several allegations were brought forward in 1989 of sexual abuse perpetrated by Br. O’Toole in Massachusetts between the late 1950s and early 1980s.


Br. O’Toole was removed from ministry in 1989.

Br. O’Toole’s name appears on the Xaverian Brothers’ list of deceased and former brothers credibly accused of sexual abusing minors.


According to the report, Br. O’Toole died in 2006.